Five Star Logo
Sarasota Five Star award winner

PROFESSIONAL ACCOMPLISHMENTS

AWARDS

  • Five Star Real Estate Agent award winner 2014-2018
  • Re/Max 100% Club winner 2014 & 1017
  • Re/Max Gold Award winner 2015 & 2016

SPECIALTIES

  • Areas of Focus: Venice
  • Nokomis
  • North Port
  • Englewood

 

08/01/2017 - dbhadley101

Sandy was very responsive to our calls and setting up appointments to see houses. She was always at the appointment before we arrived. Sandy is very easy to communicate with through texting, emails and by phone. It was a pleasure working with someone so efficient and knowledgeable and we would strongly recommend her to anyone looking for a real estate agent.

06/17/2017 - aqmajane

Sandy is very professional and knowledgable. Her advice and suggestions were very helpful, and she gave me time to think about decisions. Sandy was very easy to communicate with, and the outcome of the listing and sale of my father's home was beneficial to both myself and the buyers. I highly recommend her services. Sandy is an experienced realtor, and she understands the real estate market in Venice, Florida.

05/18/2017 - zuser20161001123523017

Sandy is extremely knowledgeable of the Venice market and tuned in quickly with what my wife and I wanted and could afford. She did not waste our time just trying to sell us, but truly tailored the search to our specifics.
She was very helpful with questions about the area and could make solid referrals for services since we were newbies to the area.

04/25/2017 - sallyalbanese

It was a pleasure to work with Sandy Sibley to fine the perfect property for me. Her knowledge, efficiency and advice helped to make this often stressful transition as easy as possible.

01/18/2017 - fredtish24

Sandra is a professional. There are many realtors that want to make money from home sales; however, few understand client respect. Sandy communicates well. She listens and is a good conversationalist. Sandy knows how to diffuse any stressful situation with a swift kindness that results in business like closure. She is moreover powerful in the Venice area community because she has developed a friendly network with other realtors. Sandy Sibley sold our home pronto because she made easy affordable suggestions that we followed. Excellent advice!

12/05/2016 - m mulhern

Both my daughter and I are new to the area. Sandy was so helpful in the process of selecting a new home for each of us. She is so skilled in her knowledge of area real estate and the process from start to finish. I wouldn't hesitate to recommending her. She is professional yet personally involved with our needs and wants.
Thank you Sandy

10/06/2016 - anne andis

I recently had the wonderful experience of working with Sandy on the sale of my parents house in Pine brook area of Venice. From our first initial meeting and through the entire process, Sandy was so friendly and very considerate of my parents limitations. She explained all aspects of the process in detail, was in constant communication, and was willing to jump in and assist with staging for the professional photographers pictures. With Sandy's knowledgeable expertise and exceptional guidance, the house was under contract within one week. My parents and I are very grateful to Sandy and highly recommend her. We feel we have made a new friend - one who is thoughtful and always has a smile on her face. Thank you Sandy!

08/22/2016 - Tom and Cathie Buzzard

We met Sandy at an open house and took an immediate liking to her openness and professionalism.
Upon contacting her for purposes of buying a home she was responsive, professional and honest with all of her interactions involved with our purchase through the closing on our new home. Sandy had an expert knowledge of the areas we searched and the nuances of living in Florida.
We would not hesitate to recommend Sandy to others as a five star real estate agent.

06/09/2016 - canderson1825

Recently, my aunt decided to sell her home in the Pinebrook area of Venice, Florida. As her devoted niece (and former realtor and current real estate investor) I was included in every part of the transactions of listing, selling and closing on her property. We interviewed several local realtors and immediately were blown away by Sandy! My aunt and I looked at each other before the interview was even over with the knowledge that we had found a true professional we wanted to work with. Her attention to detail, knowledge of the local market, use of a professional photographer (it makes a huge difference!) as well as her compassionate and thorough communication with my aunt were exemplary. Her years of experience in the Venice market combined with her hands-on hard work to make the transaction successful make Sandy someone I would HIGHLY recommend in a realtor. And, believe me, I know what it takes to be good at the job. Sandy is one of the best. And the icing on top was that the home was priced perfectly - and sold very quickly!

05/04/2016 - user779714

Sandy Sibley is an amazing realtor. She is very competent and passionate about her job. I appreciate her wonderful personality. She solved any small problems we had along the way with selling our property. She was always quickly available by phone, text or email. She made me much more comfortable in a process that, for some, can be stressful. She knows Venice and the surrounding area very well. She has many contacts in business that she is willing to share. We sold a property with her and we also found and bought a home through her. She is really nice and personable in addition to her skills as a realtor. I feel lucky to be acquainted and to have worked with her. Our family is happy and so I am happy. Thanks, Sandy!

02/07/2016 - loanberg

Sandy is friendly, warm, professional and knowledgeable. She is an expert in Pinebrook South area. I have listed my house with her and certainly recommend anyone to call Sandy if they are selling or buying home in Venice, Florida. I am very pleased with her service.

02/04/2016 - tlanigan367

Sandy worked with us to find our new home in Florida. She notified us immediately when a home came on the market we might be interested in. She was very prompt in showing us properties and responding to all our questions. Sandy is very knowledgeable of local communities. She helped through the entire process from finding a great home for us to closing. We would definitely recommend Sandy. She was great to work with!

12/16/2015 - mmooremail0

An extremely skilled and competent agent is Sandy Sibley. Having just listed and sold our home with Sandy's company, we feel she was very instrumental in our house selling in a timely manner. Her professionalism and attention to detail was above and beyond our expectations. We highly recommend her as an outstanding agent, whether selling or buying property in the Venice area.

09/26/2015 - Abbie Teachout

Our first interaction with Sandy was texting to inquire some information about a home ( we saw her sign) she contacted us within 5 minutes with the details. We were moving from Maine to Venice, Sandy sent us listings that matched our needs, she even went and video'd a home that was being auctioned, so we could decide if we wanted to make a site unseen offer. Her attention to detail saved us from possibly buying a home that would not have suited us. We arrived in Venice, she told us about the various neighborhoods, and we made an offer on a home with some folks that weren't willing to negotiate. Sandy showed us comps and we decided to continue our search. We made an offer on another home, the offer was accepted and she worked with us through the closing. Sandy was willing and available to show us multiple houses, she worked with the mortgage company and the process was a pleasure! Sandy also provided recommendations for services: Painters, Hair stylists, veterinarians, and they've worked out wonderfully!

07/25/2015 - ann freed


Sandy was tirelessly diligent, patient and professional in searching for my home with me for over a year. When we finally found my perfect house, in just the right place and in my price range, we signed the contract, had the inspections, and were so pleased, until the seller changed her mind and tried to back out of the deal. She actually fabricated a rather elaborate and dramatic story to play on sympathies and manipulate, which proved to be untrue. Sandy advocated for me, recommended the perfect local attorney,stood by me and the initially signed contract was enforced. I am in my home today, happy and so grateful that Sandy was caring, assertive and informed, and my agent!

07/02/2015 - zuser20150323124031723


I called Sandy in a house she told me about three homes. Told her what my husband was looking for. My husband is in a wheelchair she had three houses looked at the first house and that is all we need to look at. She is only amazing person. We did not have any easy mortgage company. She helped keep me & my husband culm. She went over and behond helping us and still does. I will always have an amazing realtor and now an new amazing friend!!!!

06/18/2015 - rprovencal337

Sandy is a consumate professional and extremely knowledgeable in the real estate market. She was efficient and effective in making recommendations to get the house ready to put on the market and then to video and photograph the home for exposure. I was very pleased with the process, her responsiveness and the outcome.

06/07/2015 - deborahpoor

She does what she says she will do. She's efficient, on time, professional yet warm and genuinely concerned with everyone's well being. She got me a fair price for the home I listed in less than 2 months. My son recommend her to me because he had woked with her and liked the way she got things done.

06/05/2015 - elenadunker

Working with Sandy was a pleasure! She was flexible and easily adapted to our changing needs and desires while shopping for our second home. Sandy was persistent, not pushy, efficient and experienced. Always enthusiastic, Sandy has a positive attitude which makes working with her fun!

06/03/2015 - paulathomas1978

We couldn't be more pleased with our experience of Sandy as our Buyer's Agent. She was thorough, diligent, and remarkably prompt at responding to our questions and requests. Sandy also displayed the perfect combination of professionalism and friendliness. She offered great advice when we asked for it, but didn't attempt to influence us or push anything on us. Her knowledge of the Venice housing market is extensive and we would gladly work with her again. We would highly recommend Sandy to anyone looking for a realtor.

05/31/2015 - jnelson1158

The price we got for our home was exactly what she said it was worth her knowledge of our area was very helpful in determining listing price to bring buyers to our home we were able to get a contract on our home in less than 2 weeks.

05/31/2015 - danaheyl

We had a wonderful experience with Sandy. She is extremely knowledgeable about the area, which came in handy because Florida has some very specific hurricane related requirements that impact homeowners insurance. She always communicated promptly and in detail the status of our sale. Sandy is also very tech savvy, which was important because we live in a different state. List or buy with Sandy!

05/31/2015 - ronsonsini

We were recently involved in a difficult settlement, all thru the trying process Sandy keep us informed, searched out the details and saw the settlement thru. Sandy's knowledge of not only the market but all the buying/selling processes helped out everyone.
I strongly recommend Sandy and her services for anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

05/27/2015 - jfall2

Sandy assisted my wife and I in finding a home in Venice within two days of our first trip to and arrival in Venice. Very knowledgable of the Venice area and surrounding communities. Very professional.

02/08/2015 - sethf3

You only find out how good your Realtor is when something goes wrong. Sandy recently (2/2/15) assisted us in the purchase of a home in Venice in less than 30 days. Our plans for a home in Venice were on the rocks 12/31/14. when we found out that the unit we purchased would not allow our 4 legged family member to live in our winter home. Sandy helped us document the incomplete disclosure of the sellers and their Realtor, find a new home, negotiate a new agreement. switch our mortgage application and close. Gracie is now enjoying her new Florida winter home.

11/05/2014 - philhamlin6

Sandy helped me and my wife buy our home long distance. We were living in North Carolina, vacationed here in Jan and Feb, when we met Sandy, who helped us through the entire process. She sent me listings online when we got back home, that I reviewed. Then we would talk about some of them. When we finally zeroed in on what we wanted she helped us close the deal quickly and efficiently. She was the consummate professional. I would recommend her to anyone.

10/28/2014 - dbreiner20

Sandy helped lead us through the trials and tribulations of getting our house ready, listing it, showcasing it in open house events, then quickly selling at a good price. She was great at staying connected, responding immediately to our phone calls or emails. She also kept us informed of what people thought of the home and things they saw as positives or negatives when they viewed our home.
At all times I found Sandy to be dependable, reliable, hard-working and conscientious in her relentless perseverence to the sale of our house, then advising and leading us though the closing process.
I would highly recommend Sandy Sibley as a tremendous real estate agent. To anyone considering selling a house and or purchasing another, I thoroughly recommend Sandy Sibley as a real estate agent.

10/28/2014 - susanturconi

Sandy is the best realtor I have ever worked with. She sold our home in two weeks to people who saw it on line thanks to her wonderful photos, and immediately made an offer. They were clients of Sandy which shows that she is the best buying or selling. We accepted their offer, they flew to Florida to make sure and that was it.

08/21/2014 - lcohoon

Sandy is a consummate professional. Her upbeat manner and honest approach to Real Estate are refreshing and highly effective. She is calm under pressure, fair, knowledgeable and always prompt returning calls or emails. Excellent marketing skills! Our home sold in 18 hours and closed 3 weeks later. It was a pleasure working with Sandy! Great person, great results - winning combination!

08/14/2014 - Pamela Ysidron

Sandra 'Sandy' Sibley was a life-line during a time of distress. My father had passed & she came to the aid of selling his house. It was a complicated transaction as his estate was probated and there were 4 equal beneficiaries across the nation from which Sandy had to secure approvals & document signatures. Sandy is a consummate professional, but beyond that, she lent an open ear and supplied friendly support when needed. Knowing that she would respond to all our questions & needs was a true relief during a very difficult time. From the time we said, “Go”, Sandy hit the ground running. She wasted no time in getting a Marketing Analysis, listing the Property, having an Open House, and securing a buyer. During the preparation period she gave advice on simple & inexpensive ways to improve the property, all of which were spot on. I sincerely & whole-heartedly recommend Sandy as your next Real Estate Agent. She knows how to get the job done!

07/25/2014 - Charli973

Sandy is honest, thorough, friendly, and accomplished. She helped us find the kind of home we could afford, and we both love the house. I would use her again with no hesitation.

10/24/2011 - Pete Niemczyk

Sandy was easy to work with, even in a difficult situation like ours where we were out-of-town buyers. She is very responsive and considerate. I recommend her highly.

08/31/2011 - bff1960

Sandy is professional, courteous, and responsive to client needs. She listened to my requests and followed up in a positive and timely manner. Sandy was able to respond to most of my questions without consultation. However, when she did not know an answer, she sought out the right people to get answers. I found her sensitive and patient throughout the process. I would recommend her as your realtor.

08/31/2011 - EARTHSTAR22

Sandy and I have been working together for 2 years trying to get me to Asheville, NC from Santa Fe, NM. It's been quite the adventure! We've gone through a lot together: many ups and downs with some being quite difficult. But, we finally did it and I will be moving to Asheville in 16 days! At last!

Throughout this entire process, working with Sandy has been an example of true teamwork. She has had my very best interests at heart every step of the way. Working at a great distance provided additional challenges and Sandy was unbelievably helpful and conscientious just as if she was "right next door".

I simply could not have done any of this without her .

She has a very special combination of qualities; being " the quintessential professional" in conjunction with a very warm and caring nature. No client could ask for more. I certainly couldn't and I am so grateful to have found this truly wonderful Realtor.

If you are looking to buy, to sell, rent or build, Sandy is the agent you want to be working with. She's simply THE BEST!!

Accomplishment image 1
*Winners appearing on this page do not pay a fee to be considered or to win the Five Star Award. Professionals with a digital profile have paid a promotional fee.