Five Star Logo
Sarasota Five Star award winner


Nathan Mathers

Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty
517 Bay Isles Parkway
Longboat Key, FL 34228
Office: 941.720.0408

Nathan's customers praise his work ethic, professionalism, attention to detail, depth of expertise and dependability. Nathan was voted by his past customers the 'Five Star Professional' Real Estate Agent Award in 2021-2023 for his professional excellence and superior customer service. As an agent who is an expert in this local area, combined with being trained as a Master Certified Negotiation Expert, Home Staging Expert, Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist and Senior Real Estate Specialist, Nathan brings a wealth of knowledge and expertise about buying and selling real estate. Nathan began his real estate career by door-knocking on over 4,000 residential homes in the local area to introduce his real estate services. He then achieved the honor of being awarded the 2015 Keller Williams On The Water - Bradenton 'Rookie Of The Year' due to his outstanding sales performance and then went on to be awarded the 'Sales Associate Of The Year' in 2017. Nathan also owned and operated his own real estate brokerage for 3 years prior to moving his real estate services to Premier Sotheby's International Realty. With a background as a licensed financial service representative and real estate investor, Nathan understands that buying or selling a home is one of the biggest investment decisions you will ever make and is eager to work with you to meet your goals. Nathan prides himself on taking a pro-active approach towards making the real estate buying and selling experience as stress-free as possible from the initial meeting to the day of closing.


Five Star Professional conducts market-specific research throughout the U.S. to identify service professionals who demonstrate professional excellence and provide quality services to their clients. The Five Star Real Estate Agent program is the largest and most widely published award program for real estate agents in North America, covering more than 40 major markets. Five Star award winners do not pay a fee to be included in the research or on the final list of award winners.

The Five Star Professional research team contacted thousands of recent homebuyers, consumers and industry leaders to identify Sarasota-area real estate agents who stand out in their industry and community.

To learn more about the research methodology, click here.

*Winners appearing on this page do not pay a fee to be considered or to win the Five Star Award. Professionals with a digital profile have paid a promotional fee.