New Jersey Five Star award winner



  • Five Star Real Estate Agent award winner 2014-2021


  • Areas of Focus: Monmouth, Middlesex and Ocean Counties


  • Sara Teutonico is a true professional who not only knows her field but enjoys what she does. She is wholeheartedly concerned with her clients and works hard to find them exactly what it is they are looking for. Her patience, care and concern for those she works with is first and foremost her goal. I highly recommend Sara for her hard work and dedication is first class. Keep up the great work.
  • Sara was the best agent we have ever worked with. She was always available when we needed her and always helped us with anything we needed. She got us the house we wanted at at price we wanted as well. I would recommend her to anyone and everyone!! She cared about us and what we wanted and never tries to push us into anything...which other brokers have done. 5 stars plus!!
  • We would have given Sara Teutonico 10 stars if they were shown. This is the third amazing experience my husband and I have had with Sara. She has been an angel granted to us in our times of need with purchasing, selling, moving, purchasing and moving and purchasing yet again due to work... we have never had a more complete, competent, knowledgeable, professional, diligent and concerned agent who easily moves from the beginning steps of the real estate purchase to local area information, etc. to day of sale and even follows up with you afterward. We all know how difficult the process can be but with Sara, it flowed and all of her expertise comes through and takes you from step one to completion with the ease of a consummate professional. We cannot say enough about her and if we EVER need to do this process again, she is the only name we need.
  • I cannot fully express in words how dedicated, knowledgeable, accessible, and personable a realtor Sara is. From start to finish, Sara was always available to answer any questions (even when I asked the same question multiple times), speedily answered calls and emails, easily scheduled appointments to view homes, and also provided valuable guidance. Her expertise, coupled with her pleasant personality, allowed for a very high level of comfort and assurance throughout the overall home buying process.

    It is immediately and continually evident that Sara keeps your best interests, requests and desires in mind at all times, and works to meet/exceed all of them. Sara truly goes above and beyond. She worked endlessly to ensure that I had more than an ample amount of listings to view that fit nicely within my budget and desired area, and was patient, caring, and positive at all times. It was thanks to her that I experienced a smooth purchase process, and moreover, peace of mind in knowing that I ultimately purchased my home at the best possible price.

    It is with no qualms that I would strongly recommend Sara to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She will be an invaluable asset in your real estate journey, and you will be in the best and most caring hands with her as your agent

*Winners appearing on this page do not pay a fee to be considered or to win the Five Star Award. Professionals with a digital profile have paid a promotional fee.