Sarasota Five Star award winner


Midge McCarthy

Broker Associate
5119 Willow Leaf Dr
Sarasota, FL 34241
Office: 941-809-3800
Cell: 941-809-3800

  • Midge is an excellent realtor and wonderful person to work with. She is a seasoned real estate professional with an in depth knowledge of the local market. She was extremely patient and spent many weeks with us spread out over several months to find us the perfect home. She has an extensive network of contacts among the local community - this was very useful during our search, in purchasing the home, and after we moved in. We would highly recommend Midge as a professional expert.
  • Myself and family members have used Midge as our realtor many times to sell and to buy houses . She is so knowledgeable is all the aspects of buying and selling real estate and was always very helpful and always had our back ! I have referred Midge to many people I knew who needed a really knowledgeable realtor In their corner ! She is absolutely a genuine person who always goes that extra mile for her clients!! I have heard that from soo many people she has helped to buy or sell a home for ! You cannot go wrong with Midge !
  • Midge is awesome. She is a true professional who actually listens to your needs and then performs! I recommend her in the highest possible way. We were very happy with the support she gave us.
  • Midge McCarthy has very high work ethic standards, and truly cares about her clients. We were in especially difficult situation selling our vacation home in Sarasota remotely (with very limited opportunity to travel and take care of the property), and Midge has done a great job filling many of the gaps we had on maintenance and other matters, including an especially challenging period after the hurricane Irma. For a number of reasons (a major remodeling was one of them) not related to the quality of Midge's services, our property was on the Market for over 8 months, so at times it seemed very frustrating, with no end in site, but Midge would never loose hope, she would always keep a positive attitude and hard work, and those are the qualities that never fail to do the job right. There was a happy ending to our story (as I am sure was to many other stories), because of Midge's skills, perseverance, and strong sense of responsibility to her clients.
  • Midge McCarthy is the ultimate professional! What a pleasure it was to have her experience and knowledge for any request. The land we were looking at was loaded with difficult problems and complicated requirements from the developer. Midge was able to obtain every bit of the information we needed and presented it to us in a clear and simple format. We ultimately decided not to build our new home in this development, but we will definitely look forward to working with Midge again. The only regret we have have is that there is not a rating higher than 5 stars! Thanks Midge!


Five Star Professional conducts market-specific research throughout the U.S. to identify service professionals who demonstrate professional excellence and provide quality services to their clients. The Five Star Real Estate Agent program is the largest and most widely published award program for real estate agents in North America, covering more than 40 major markets. Five Star award winners do not pay a fee to be included in the research or on the final list of award winners.

The Five Star Professional research team contacted thousands of recent homebuyers, consumers and industry leaders to identify Sarasota-area real estate agents who stand out in their industry and community.

To learn more about the research methodology, click here.

*Winners appearing on this page do not pay a fee to be considered or to win the Five Star Award. Professionals with a digital profile have paid a promotional fee.